Book Review: Dragons in our Midst

Have you noticed the lack of good, Christian fiction for boys and men?  Go to the bookstore, or check out on line sites and you'll find racks upon racks, page after page listing what appears to be "Christian Romance".  Sorry, but I'm looking for something to engage my *son*.  Something not only entertaining but also true to Biblical standards.  It also has to be well written.

So just by chance my wife picked out the 4 books in the Dragons in our Midst series by Bryan Davis for my son's 11th birthday.  Having no idea really about these books, we decided to let our 11 year old give them a try. 

He finished the last one less than a week later.

This month I finally got around to reading them myself.  There's no way I can keep up with either my son or my daughter in the number of books they read. My wife throws her back out every week with the weight of all the books they check out from our local library and we are personally responsible for saving several dozen books from the dust bins.  It's sad to see a good book that hasn't been checked out for over a year.  So, in short, my children are voracious readers.

As I said, I finally determined to read these 4 books and see why my son enjoyed them so much. 

Where to start?

Book one, Raising Dragons, introduces all the major players and sets the scene and tone for the entire series.  Our main hero - there are several - is William Bannister, or Billy as he is often called.  At age 14 Billy is wondering when he'll have to start shaving, how to deal with the school bully, and other typical teenage concerns.  But Billy also has been keeping a secret from his parents:  His breath has become super hot!  He soon discovers he's not the only one to keep secrets.  His father, Jared, is well over a thousand years old and used to be a dragon.

Soon everyone is battling dragon slayers, discovering their dragon abilities, and finding that faith in God is essential to humans as well as dragons.  Billy must learn to trust in God, his friends, and his father to defeat his enemies and save his loved ones.

The entire series is so full of excitement and adventure that I was beginning to wonder how any of the characters would survive.  Each novel is a real page-turner.  The battles rage, the escapes are harrowing, and the perils indeed quite perilous.  The Christian faith is completely woven throughout and fills every little space.

There is some romance, but it is very respectful and appropriate for young readers as an example of how young men and women should treat each other.  Billy overcomes temptation in various forms throughout the series and gains strength from each victory.  The violence of battle is not overly graphic and is necessary as good must battle against evil.  These Christians aren't wimpy but instead stand fast in their faith.  They get bruised and bloodied to be sure, but they persevere and triumph in the end.

Now for the bad news:  I cannot fault Davis for his vision nor his storytelling.  He has produced a compelling and entertaining world of faith, magic, and just a little science that almost reaches the level of Asimov, Niven, and Tolkien.

I did say almost.

It's not the style.  The stories flow like a wild roller coaster and all you can do is hang on for the ride.  There is good, evil, and those that are redeemed. As I said earlier, Christian faith is woven throughout and is vital to our heroes.  Don't expect a work of fiction to be one-hundred percent consistent with every brand of Christianity, however. This is fiction, not doctrine and certain liberties must be taken. 

Some may wonder about bending Biblical truths too much.  Again, this falls under the heading of "literary license" and we must put on our "willing suspension of disbelief" for both science fiction and religious fiction.  While there isn't anything specifically Biblical about the alternative dimensions in Circles of Seven, there are enough references to different levels of Heaven and Hell for us to allow for fictional accounts.  If we didn't, we'd have to throw out Pilgrim's Progress and other great works.

It's not the characters.  Each one struggles with their inner doubts and has a unique personality.  Sure, the professor seems to know just a bit too much about EVERYTHING, but that's why he's a professor! And Walter is definitely there for comic relief as is the supercomputer, Larry.

Hmm... Let's talk about the Larry the supercomputer.  Those scenes and those involving the pseudo-science described in The Candlestone tend to sound a lot like the techno-babble used in Star Trek.  You're left saying "What?" while rolling your eyes. These scenes are definitely "B-movie" quality and stick out from the rest of the books.

I'm a big fan of Star Trek and other works of science fiction and I can overlook the techno-babble.  Really, every science fiction writer at some point has to make something up.  Otherwise we wouldn't have time machines, transfer booths, or faster-than-light travel. Why bring it up then?  The sudden change from fantasy and adventure to science fiction took me by surprise.  Something just didn't fit together well and stopped the flow of the story.

Also, I was a little disappointed that Billy's coming to faith in Christ happens in the background and isn't overtly described.  In fact, there are no outright examples of conversion.  That's not all bad, as I've waded through several stories where the authors present you with a seven-point essay on how to get saved in the guise of one character witnessing to another.  I don't expect fiction novels to be tools for witnessing and I don't want to be hit over the head with four or five examples of explaining the Gospel. But Billy is our HERO and his faith in Christ is a major weapon in his battle against evil.  He struggled with doubt for so long and then suddenly, POP "I'm a believer".  I do wish this part was fleshed out just a little bit.

The main reason these novels almost, but not quite, reach the top level is a failure in editing.  There are a few loose threads that aren't completed, leaving me wondering "why?" and "how?".  Also, there are a few internal inconsistencies that should be cleared up, such as when one villain is destroyed yet their number doesn't decrease. 

Every fault I can find with Dragons in our Midst can easily be fixed in the second edition and will turn this series from great to fantastic!  I specifically chose Asimov, Niven, and Tolkien for comparisons as each one displayed similar issues with their works.  Asimov had a planet with a pure oxygen atmosphere - not possible but he left it in because the story would have to be completely reworked otherwise.  Niven had to reengineer the Ring World to make it stable. Tolkien had to edit his works to fix inconsistencies as well.  We don't remember them for the corrections but for the overall quality of the work.  Bryan Davis fits in that category as well. 

Overall, Dragons in our Midst is exceptional.  The novels are easy to read yet highly engaging and are just right for young readers and completely enjoyable for older ones as well. I look forward to more works from Bryan Davis.

 del.icio.us  Stumbleupon  Technorati  Digg 

 
Trackbacks
  • Trackbacks are closed for this entry.
Comments

  • 8/1/2006 12:27 PM Bryan Davis wrote:
    Thank you for the positive review and encouraging words. I appreciate your kindness. I know what it's like trying to find entertaining and uplifting books for young readers, especially boys. That's why I wrote the series in the first place.

    I would be interested in the specifics of what you found that left you wondering "why" and "how." The explanations might be available, and perhaps I erred in making them too subtle.

    I'd also like to discuss Billy's conversion, so I hope to see you on my message board soon, and we can chat. I don't want to plant any spoilers here, but there was a specific episode in "The Candlestone" that was supposed to be Billy's conversion experience.

    Anway, I am grateful for your review. You captured the spirit and essence of what I was trying to do with these books. I am very thankful that they were well received in your home.

    I hope you'll enjoy the new book, Eye of the Oracle, as well. It comes out in September.
    Reply to this
  • 8/2/2006 1:54 PM Roger Drury wrote:
    Finally got to the site! Probably will only last a little while on a different server. Interesting review. I'm curious why you feel only certain books can carry moral messages? Of course, I'm not very well read in childrens or even young adult books any more. You mentioned Tolken, which I'm a bit more familiar with - while his books aren't Christian, they do address loyalty, courage, standing up for what's right, and making choices. There certainly isn't anything wrong with Biblical themes, but should books that do not carry those themes be discouraged?
    Reply to this
    1. 8/3/2006 10:08 AM James Drury wrote:
      Welcome Brother Roger!

      I didn't mean to imply that only certain books can carry a moral message.  Indeed, nearly all stories have some morality.  It's a question of whose morality.

      We've read many of the Star Wars novels in the "Young Jedi" series. They have a strong moral of Good vs Evil and that Good will triumph.  The Bionicle books have the same idea.  The Good Guys must work together as a team and overcome their differences to defeat the Bad Guys.  These are all, by and large, good stories and I consider them "Mostly Harmless" in that there isn't any issue with language or "adult situations".

      What I was lamenting was the lack of solidly written Christian fiction - stories written from a specific world view. Specifically, Christian fiction for boys or at least suitable for boys.  There are some, to be sure, but most of the novels I've seen in catalogs either fall into the "Girl" section or "Christian Romance".  Your nephew isn't interested in reading page after page of "...her heart leaped for joy as Stephen swept Victoria up in his well-muscled, tan arms.  She looked longingly into his handsome features as her own face was mirrored in his deep blue eyes.  This was the man God had intended for her and she silently thanked Him for this wonderful...."  You get the picture.

      Many Christian novels just aren't very good.  They may have a good plot, or good characters, but the quality of writing isn't there for fiction.  Historical Fiction is an exception, which is usually well written.  But how many stories about George Washington's youth can you read?

      Part of my job as Dad is to protect my children from what I believe may be harmful.  Certainly we can understand the physical harm that may come from getting too close to a cliff or other danger.  It's my job to stand between my kids and that danger.  In the same way, I must watch out for spiritual dangers.  We don't use certain language in our house for a few reasons including the fact that I believe it corrupts their integrity and degrades their ability to communicate.  I've worked with several individuals that include an extra word in front of every noun they speak: "this F-n tool", "that F-n guy", "Oh, we are so f-ed".  They have apparently forgotten how to use any other adjective.

      Also, since Caleb is only 11 and Christen 9, there is a lot of sexual innuendo that they aren't ready to handle.  I don't want them getting their morality from Sit-coms (where there really isn't any), nor do I want them to read about encounters in novels.  I really enjoy science fiction novels and so does Caleb but I don't want him reading Larry Niven or other authors that spend a lot of time describing explicit sexual encounters in zero-gravity.  When he's older and has a firm understanding of the entire situation then he can make his own decisions.  But for now, that's my job.

      No, books that aren't specifically Christian aren't discouraged.  We read tons and tons of them.  But I'm discouraged by the lack of attention to this audience by either authors or publishers.  I don't know which is really to blame.  Perhaps pure market forces are pushing demand for other books up.

      That's why I'm excited about the Dragons in our Midst novels by Bryan Davis.  Sure, I found a few faults but they were so minor!  As I said in the review, just a bit more editing would bump these novels up a notch or two.  Most readers probably won't even notice, just curmudgeons like your brother.
      Reply to this
  • 8/14/2006 9:53 AM Darin wrote:
    Thanks, James. Eli is always in need of MORE BOOKS, and it's hard to find good ones. I will enjoy these too -- but I wonder if I should wait for 2nd edition and Eye of the Oracle? (no)
    Reply to this
    1. 8/18/2006 12:08 PM James Drury wrote:
      Certainly not!  Don't wait!  It's only my opinion so take it for what it's worth.  It's very easy to find faults with someone else's work as opposed to creating something yourself. 

      I've been wondering if I should remove that "2nd Edition" comment.  I'll leave it there but I'll just say again that the items I noticed were very minor.
      Reply to this
  • 8/14/2006 10:26 AM Kathy Petty wrote:
    James,

    I enjoyed your book review. I guess I'll have to go buy the books so Eli can read them. (Yes, of course I want to read them too.) Eli has a group of friends who enjoy sharing what they are reading and this sounds like a perfect series for them. I have been very hesitant about leading Eli into science fiction/fantasy because of the worldviews the writers project.
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name (required)

 Email (will not be published) (required)

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.